Letter: An Open Letter to WHPS Staff and PTOs
Audio By Carbonatix

We-Ha.com welcomes Letters to the Editor from the public, including endorsements. Letters submitted by political candidates will be considered for publication up to 14 days prior to an election and most will be published within 48 hours of receipt. Letters that contain personal attacks or include profanity of any type will not be published. Rebuttals to letters should be submitted as a separate document if possible. Please provide your full name and town, as well as your phone number at the end of the letter. Phone numbers will not be published but are required in case verification is needed. Please submit letters to [email protected].
Dear West Hartford principals, teachers and PTO heads,
I can’t help but notice the use of generative AI posters, communication materials, and flyers being shared to promote school, district, and PTO-related events. While I understand that issues such as staffing and time constraints may result in individuals looking for a quick solution, there are many other free software programs and websites that can produce this content without the help of AI.
The West Hartford Public School statement on AI says that the district supports “the school community in the ethical, authentic, and innovative use of AI.” I’d like to highlight some of the reasons that this statement is problematic:
Theft of intellectual property: Generative AI posters and “art” is made by stealing assets from the work of artists and people’s photos without their permission. This harms the artists, writers, and creatives whose work was used without consent to build AI models.
Destructive to the environment: As many of us are aware, generative AI is rapidly denegrating our environment through a reckless use of water and electricity, which is antithetical to the ethos of respecting nature. If our hope is to teach young people to value and care for the planet, supporting AI use sends mixed messages.
Privacy concerns: When information, including specifics of times and dates of school events, is put into AI software, it is stored in an unregulated, non-secure database. It is unclear which third parties have access to this data and how it will be used.
Academic integrity and standards: Any learning environment, like our schools, ought to have the highest standards for quality and authenticity in work, including art. Generative AI slop often includes spelling and grammar errors, inaccuracies, and illustration errors.
Disrespect towards the audience: Although the news keeps proclaiming that AI is “getting better” and can produce seamless content, most recipients can discern when generative AI has been used in a communication. This cheapens and devalues the communication, as it was not worth human time or effort to compose.
Lack of humanistic values: I would like my children to grow in a human-centered world, in which values such as empathy, critical thinking, moral responsibility, and interconnectedness are the driving force. AI generated content devalues human imagination and creative potential by centering algorithms and compute power over human communities.
Thank you very much for reading this letter. I would ask the leadership of the West Hartford Public Schools to revisit their AI statement, with these points in mind. I also ask WHPS staff and PTO leads to reflect on the ethical trade offs of a quick and easy path to making a flyer or poster.
Lindsay Cook
West Hartford

