Letter: West Hartford Voters Deserve a Say on Flock Cameras
Audio By Carbonatix

We-Ha.com welcomes Letters to the Editor from the public, including endorsements. Letters submitted by political candidates will be considered for publication up to 14 days prior to an election and most will be published within 48 hours of receipt. Letters that contain personal attacks or include profanity of any type will not be published. Rebuttals to letters should be submitted as a separate document if possible. Please provide your full name and town, as well as your phone number at the end of the letter. Phone numbers will not be published but are required in case verification is needed.
Please submit letters to [email protected].
Please note that any election-related letter to the editor must be submitted by Sunday, Nov. 1 in order to be included in the newsletter on Monday, Nov. 2, which is the last one before election day. And please note that only one letter per person regarding the same candidate in the same race will be published.
Dear Editor,
As a lifelong registered Democrat, I was very disappointed by Tiffani McGinnis’s response to concerns about Flock cameras at the recent debate between the candidates for state representative in the 18th District.
Earlier this year, Councilor McGinnis gave a speech at the Free America Walkout about the incompatibility of oppression and democracy, responding to ICE crackdowns on immigrants and protesters in Minnesota. I appreciated her willingness to speak out. But those concerns should also extend to the surveillance tools being used here in West Hartford.
Flock cameras collect information about vehicles and their movements, raising serious questions about privacy, government access to data, and the potential impact on vulnerable communities. Residents have raised these concerns with town leaders and asked for a public discussion.
To his credit, Republican candidate Philip Tummescheit has called for something residents have been asking for: an open hearing on Flock cameras. At the 18th District debate, he said he had heard from many residents who opposed the cameras. He also said he would support legislation allowing residents to petition for a ballot measure on whether their movements around town should be tracked.
Councilor McGinnis said the cameras help investigate serious crimes and acknowledged people’s concerns. But instead of calling for a public hearing or taking a clear position on West Hartford’s use of the cameras, she suggested that the state legislature review the Police Officer Standards and Training Council’s recommendations and consider stricter standards or limits.
That is a meaningful difference. Mr. Tummescheit is calling for residents to be heard and potentially have a vote. Councilor McGinnis is looking to the legislature to consider what standards or limits might be appropriate. Meanwhile, the cameras remain in use, and residents are still waiting for a public debate.
As a member of West Hartford’s Public Safety Committee, Councilor McGinnis has an opportunity to push for that discussion now. Will she support a public hearing? Does she believe residents should have a say in whether these cameras are used? And does she support their continued use under the town’s current practices?
Town leaders should also explain the evidence behind their support for Flock cameras. An Atlanta Community Press Collective analysis of FBI data found that Atlanta’s crime clearance rates did not meaningfully increase from 2021 to 2025, despite a major expansion of the city’s surveillance camera network, which includes Flock cameras.
The evidence deserves scrutiny – not just assurances that the cameras work. If West Hartford’s leaders believe they improve public safety, they should share the data and studies supporting that conclusion. They should also respond to the outstanding Freedom of Information requests for Flock-related data, some of which have been pending for many months.
This should not be a partisan issue. It is a question of transparency, accountability, and whether the people whose movements are being tracked get a voice in the decision. Philip Tummescheit has put forward a constructive approach, and I hope West Hartford Republicans will join him in calling for a public hearing and a meaningful opportunity for residents to be heard. I also urge Councilor McGinnis and the town’s Democratic leaders to do the same. West Hartford deserves an honest debate about whether these cameras belong in our community.
Arman Haidari
West Hartford


Tiffani definitely lost the debate and not only on this issue.,. Democrats who never consider voting outside of the party line need to consider the facts of her stances and record: she admits she is unable to lower taxes and also how she is only in this for herself as she does not want to listen to the public about flock cameras- if you are a Democrat reading this please consider splitting your ticket and vote for Philip- Tiffani is not listening to you.
The town council not responding to FOIA requests and ignoring residents’ concerns about their privacy shows a lack of transparency and respect for the voice of their voters. We expect better from our elected leaders.
I believe Flock cameras should be up to the voters of West Hartford. Town surveillance should be up to the citizens of our town. I two would like to see the statistics that warrant this surveillance.
Never thought I would see the day where Republicans are the only ones asking substantive questions about our town council putting Silicon Valley bros mass surveillance tools on our streets that are being used to harass women and minorities. Always happy to have press conferences virtual signalling protecting people, but actual governance and accountability on it, nah…. Don’t be fooled when they tell you its locked down now, or you are safe now– they put it on our streets with no input, no ordinance, and no protection for citizens.
It’s common sense to allow and encourage a public hearing and discussion on something that impacts the privacy and security of everyone in town. It’s very shady to block even the idea of a public debate and discussion. As a new West Hartford homeowner who is excited to live here, I am wondering why we are so far behind Windsor, Killingworth, and East Lyme on this issue. It’s puzzling and makes me wonder why town leadership isn’t listening to which way the wind is blowing on this. This won’t age well, and I don’t feel safer with these cameras on the streets.
Disappointed with McGinnis on this matter, but can NEVER forgive or forget that the GOP will bring about – if they can (and they might yet succeed) – a complete Trump/GOP fascist dictatorship ,,, so I can never, ever vote GOP again at ANY level of government. Sometimes you have to choose between the lesser of two evils, and I’ve chosen.
The point about town leaders not providing evidence that these cameras actually work is such an important one. I guess we’re supposed to take their word for it? The cameras have been in place (without our knowledge or consent) for years, so by now they should have plenty of data showing how effective they are. It’s telling that they haven’t provided any.
Great stuff, Arman.
I vote in every election.
I will never vote for another politician who does not make lifting the net of digital surveillance off the populace a main priority.
Google Grace Knowles. That’s our present. It doesn’t have to be our future.
Tiffani, Why do you choose to side with private, third party companies that would surveille West Hartford residents without consent, instead of engaging with the will of those who elected you to office? This kind of behavior shows to us that you are more concerned with falling in line with the fascist, and un-American efforts of the Trump regime. Hear West Hartford out! We’ve done our homework. Flock, or any other form of mass surveillance stands NO chance per the American people. Stop wasting time and money on an effort bound to fail and show your constituents some decency.